William H. Heitzman (Apr. 1906–Dec. 1908) Born in Kingston, NY in 1874, he died in November 1948.

Garrett H. White (Jan. 1909–Dec. 1910). He died in January 1919.

Jesse P. Manahan (Jan. 1911–Dec. 1916). Born in Long Branch in May 1861, he died in April 1922 in Red Bank (where was was a councilman).

Abram O. Johnson (Jan. 1917–Dec. 1926). Born in North Long Branch in October 1878, he died in August 1950 at his Riverdale Avenue home.

George Y. Van Brunt (Jan. 1927–Dec. 1928). Born in Long Branch in 1898, he died in January 1981 an Ocean Grove resident.

Maxwell B. Smith (Jan. 1929–Oct. 1929). Born in 1883 in New York, he died in January 1935.

John J. Campbell (Oct. 1929–May 1933). Born in NYC, he died in March 1934 in NYC.

William F. Carhart (May 1933–May 1937). Born in New York City in 1899, he died in March 1964 in MB.

Abram O. Johnson (May 1937–May 1945).

G. Henry Mihm (May 1945–May 1949). Born in MB in 1898, he died in November 1979 in MB.

Sidney B. Johnson (May 1949–June 1978). Born in MB in 1915, he died in March 2001 in MB.

F. Brent Neale (June 1978–May 1981). Born in New York in 1919, he died in February 1992.

Louis P. Sodano (May 1981–May 1997).

James P. McConville, III (May 1997–May 2005).

Susan J. Howard (May 2005–August 2020).